Should You Take The Gig Or Pass?

Don't Make This Mistake With Your Email List

How To Make A Music Video On A Tiny Budget

How To Make The Most Amount Of Tips At The Gig

9 Things You Didn't Know About The College Music Market

Is Your Facebook Musician Page Doing More Hurt Than Help?

What Is SoundExchange, ASCAP, BMI, PROs, HFA And How To Get All Your Royalties

9 Essential Things Every Musician Must Have In 2016

Why Exactly Is Spotify Being Sued And What Does This Mean?

When Greeting Fans, Never Say 'Nice to Meet You'

5 Incentives To Get Fans To Sign Your Email List Online

This Band Lost $3,000 At Their Record Release Show In LA

What To Do When Everything At The Show Goes To Shit

To Own Your City You Need To Find Your Jam

How To Turn Your Fans Into Paying Subscribers

How To Get Music In Podcasts (And Make Money...Legally)

This Artist Lost 2,000 Potential Fans In Two Hours Because Of This

8 Reasons Why Singer/Songwriter Shows Are Boring

12 Ways To Get More Facebook Likes (And Engagement) For Your Musician Page

10 Reasons Why You're Failing At Instagram

How To Guarantee Your Music Is Heard By A Film/TV Supervisor

What Bands Who Broke Up Made Me Realize

11 Mistakes Every Young Band Makes

How To Objectively Pick Your Best Songs (Or Find Out If You Suck)

The Reason You Never Get An Email Response

How To Legally Release Cover Songs

How To Get Your Music On NPR

How Much You Should Be Charging For Merch

Why You Shouldn't Promote Your Music On iTunes

9 Things To Consider When Choosing A Music Venue

11 Reasons Why You're Failing At Open Mics

How My (Mini) Tour Taught Me To Love Performing Again

The Biggest Mistake Bands Make With Lyrics

Don't Play To The Assholes

Hey Midwest! Join Me At The Music Biz Meetups

You Can Pay Important People To Listen To Your Music

Phish At The Forum: A Teachable Moment For Every Band

How To See Your Listener Data On Pandora

No Deal Is What It Is

This Company Will Print, Label And Ship Tour Posters

How To Get More Mailing List Subscribers

8 Things You're Forgetting To Do On Show Day

How To Easily Rent Gear On The Road

Drop Your Ego And Book A House Concert Tour

Tour Booking Will Never Be The Same After This

10 Social Media Mistakes Bands Make

How To Write a Press Release (And Get Press)

9 Reasons Your Band Isn't Getting Press

Get Ari's Take On Your Album At The Next Meetup

Top Music YouTubers Reveal Their Secrets At VidCon

How To Get Your Band Info Synched Everywhere At Once

7 Ways To Crack The Musical Gatekeepers

6 Types Of Emails You Should Never Send

How To Make Money From Your Music On An Ongoing Basis

How To Get Songs Placed On TV And In Movies

How To Hire Freelance Musicians

Why Music Managers Just Don't Cut It (The NEW Team)

How To Be A Classy Self-Promoter

When Paying For Music Works

Why Are People (Not) Coming To Your Shows?

What Musicians Can Learn From The Olympics

Network Like A Music Pro At The First Ari's Take Meetup

What I Learned From My $12 Cup Of Coffee

How To Submit To Pandora (Without a CD)

Why I Hate Downloading Music

Don’t Be Late. Ever.

How To Copyright All of Your Songs For $55

How To Act Completely Unprofessionally

CD Baby, Tunecore, DistroKid, Ditto, Mondotunes, ReverbNation, Symphonic or...

8 Ways To Get The Best Deal For The Gig

How To Make A Killer Promo Video

Carry Your Instrument On The Plane - It's The LAW

10 Steps To Sell Out Your Show

Your Gear Will Get Stolen

Why Retweeting Compliments Is Not Bragging

Yes, You Need T-Shirts

How To Record Your Album

How To Network Like A (Music) Pro

My Response To An LA Pay-To-Play Promoter

Should You Pay To Play

9 Reasons Why You Have No Twitter Followers

You Don't Find A Manager, A Manager Finds You

CD Baby Pro vs. TuneCore Publishing (The Full Report)

Don't Try Out For A Singing Show...

This Is How I Got A Licensing Deal

The One Thing Musicians Should Never Admit

How To Kill a 30 Year Career in 5 Minutes

The Art of Asking

Skip The Party Tonight, Become a Rockstar Tomorrow

How To Pimp Out Your CD Release Show

You Should Try Out for American Idol (The Relatives)

Free Bird! (Covers vs. Originals)

What's a Publicist and Should I Get One?

Copyright Your Song or GLEE Will Steal It

How To Setup A Headlining Show

9 Things Every Musician Needs To Know About The Sound Guy

Interview with founder of Indie On The Move

Why No One Cares About Your Music

Booking Your Own Tour: A How-To Guide

Fuck Facebook... In the Face

Technical Difficulties ARE Your Fault

50 Is The Magic Number (Book a Headlining Tour)

Always Do This When Giving Your CD To Someone Important

How I Made $13,544 In A Month (on Kickstarter)

Smash Your Shitty Guitar

Are You In The Right City For Your Music

The Hardest Part About Being Your Own Manager

Buy My Music Dammit (Spotify vs iTunes)

How To Be A Great Opening Act

Rockstars Are People Too

It Doesn't Take a Web Genius

What Do You Mean We Don't Get Paid? (The Confirmation Email)

How To Be A Better Performer

How I Got To Play The World's Largest Music Festival

Does This Mustache Make My Ass Look Fat?

Our Tour Page Is Totally Full (of empty shows)

Don't Be Afraid Of The Phone

I Think You're An Asshole, So I'm Going To Tell You, Asshole

Don't Be A Dick

How I Got 250 To My Debut CD Release (Getting Started)

Can I Open For You? Maybe. But Probably Not

How I Reduced The Ari Herstand Hate Club By One

How To Double Your (Merch) Income... No Really

Beauty School Drop Out (The Backup Plan)

Shows Sell, Events Sell Out

I'm A Tool and I Have Accepted That

Allocating the Duties

Friend Fatigue

Ari's Take

Should You Take The Gig Or Pass?


I want to clear up a few things after yesterday's 9 Times It's OK To Ask Musicians To Play For Free bombshell. 99% of you got it was sarcasm. But for the 1%, heyyyyoooo! I got your emails. 

And also, I posted it to Digital Music News to reach the broader music community - namely the butthole promoters and "talent buyers" who try to convince artists to play for free - when they themselves are making money.

But since you all, oh wonderful Ari's Take community, are musicians. I want to lay out some practices on how you can figure out if you should take a gig or not.

Remember, nothing in the music industry is black and white. Not streaming. Not pirating music. Not playing gigs for free. Is playing for free ever ok? Short answer is yes. Should bands take free gigs? Short answer is maybe. But nothing in the music industry can accurately be answered with a short answer.

Use this guide to help you decide if the gig is right for you:


Don't take a gig unless it meets The Perfect 30 Test:

Payment = 10. Career building = 10. Enjoyment = 10.

You don't want to play any shows for less than a total of 15 on the scale. If the payment is incredible (10), but there will be very little career building potential (3) or enjoyment (2), that equals 15. If there is decent payment (5), but will bring great enjoyment (9), but little career building potential (1), that also equals a 15. Take these shows. The shows you shouldn't take are the ones for little to no money (1), very little career building potential (3) and very little enjoyment (3) = 7 total. Pass!


Of course the decision to take a free gig is up to you, but as someone who has played countless free gigs I can tell you the ones that I'd do again for free and the ones I definitely would not. There are a few instances when free gigs are no brainers:

For Charity or A Worthy Cause

If you believe in the cause or the organization, then absolutely offer your services free of charge. Your "normal performance fee" can sometimes be a tax deductible donation for certain organizations. Always ask the org. You can also always ask the organizers if they have a "stipend" for you. Can't hurt to ask. Oftentimes they will have a bit of a budget. So if your normal performance rate is $500, they may be able to give you a stipend of $100 (and you may even also be able to write off $400 as a tax deductible donation).

As a Favor or Trade

Sometimes your friends are throwing an event and will most likely lose money on it. It's always cool to play for your buddies' and ladies' parties or events for no charge because they're your people. Maybe they're a graphic design artist or a videographer or a doctor. Maybe you need a logo, a music video or a check up. Bartering is sometimes even better than cash.

Sitting In

Sitting in is a time honored tradition in the singer/songwriter and jam communities. But every band should do it at some point. It's when you call up a friend to sing harmonies or rip a solo. Or even just join you on stage with a tambourine. It's an honor and an endorsement of that artist. Of course, the host band should announce the artist's name who sat in and give their project a plug. Fans love to see this kind of community building. Some of my favorite shows are ones where the main act brought out special guests. These guests aren't paid. They're doing it because they want to. It's usually a lot of fun to step outside your performance norm and it can also help promote upcoming shows.

For Practice

If you're new to the performance thing or your band just formed, you need practice performing. Young bands should take any and every performance opportunity. Most often these will be free shows. In LA (and unfortunately it's starting to happen more frequently around the country), "promoters" will get bands to pay-to-play in sneaky ways like requiring them to sell a certain number of tickets for their set. And if they don't meet their quota they have to make up the difference. Or, sometimes the "promoter" keeps all income from the first 50 tickets sold and then the band keeps the rest - or something absurd like that (at $10 a pop that's $500 off the top to the promoter. 5 bands on the bill, $2,500 to the promoter before any band earns $1!). Do not take the bait. Find low pressure performance environments to hone your chops where they don't charge you to play (ahh!) - but you may not get paid either. That's ok. You don't deserve to yet.

Strong Merch / Tip Potential

Ok, this is slippery. Because bookers will promise you good merch/tip potential and rarely does it work out to be so. However, sometimes it really can be. I performed a small side stage at "The World's Largest Music Festival" Summerfest in Milwaukee 2-3 times a day for 4 years and I averaged about $300 A SET in merch and tips. Yeah, the fest didn't pay me anything to play this stage, but I made up for it in the regularity of the performance slots and the merch/tip income. 

We can debate how ethical this was for the festival to do, but regardless, I walked away from the 11 day festival $8,000 richer every year. Not bad.

For Enjoyment

Like The Perfect 30 test, sometimes you know you're going to just have a darn good time. And isn't that what life is all about?

As a Creative Outlet

This argument is used by hobbyists. There are the school teachers, bankers, construction workers and others with full time jobs that have nothing to do with music and these hard-working dayjobbers are just looking for a creative outlet. A way to express themselves artistically, openly and outwardly. In front of an audience. Unfortunately, these hobbyist musicians accepting the free gigs undercuts the professionals. Because of this, the pros have a much more difficult time demanding a fair price for their performances. I don't encourage the "creative outlet" practice, but it happens and there are many hobbyists who fall into this category.

Dear all hobbyists, please ask for a fair price for your performance. Because if you don't, you're hurting those who are trying to make their livings with their art. Love, professional artists everywhere. 

Like these tips? Support my Patreon or give me a tip!

Ari Herstand (pronounced Ar*ee Her*stand) is a Los Angeles based singer/songwriter. Follow him on Twitter, Instagram and Facebook.

blog comments powered by Disqus